Skip to article

ACCELYST INSIGHTS

When is more traffic worth paying for?

·
November 19, 2026

IN BRIEF

Before approving a larger paid-search budget, ask how many additional orders it would take to cover the increase. Divide the proposed spend increase by what an order leaves after the cost of the product, fulfillment and other variable costs. That gives you a break-even number. It also gives you a question worth putting to whoever runs the website. What would it cost to earn those orders from people already coming to the store?

A consumer products manufacturer came to Accelyst because it wanted more of its website visitors to buy. We changed how the site presented the products and how shoppers moved through a purchase. We also reconfigured Google Ads using the conversions attributed to each channel and put a price increase into effect.

The manufacturer’s Shopify report recorded 286 sessions that ended in a completed checkout from August 11 through September 22, 2025. That was 23% more than in the June 29 through August 10 period. Traffic rose 16%, and the share of visits ending in checkout reached 1.23%, a 6% relative increase. More people came, and a slightly larger share bought. Those figures cover the whole store and predate our later refinements to product pages, listings and checkout. They can’t tell us which change earned an extra order or whether another dollar of advertising would pay for itself. Manufacturer engagement and reporting notes

For your own spending decision, pick one product the larger budget is supposed to sell. Look at the searches you’d be paying for. Someone typing your product name into Google arrives with a different question from someone still deciding which product fits. A forecast that applies the store’s average conversion rate to both visitors misses that difference.

Then follow the search to the page where the shopper lands. If customers routinely call to ask which of two models fits, put the answer where they choose and test whether more of them buy. If the searches you plan to expand already bring in orders at a cost your margin supports, try a limited increase. Judge it by what you spent for each additional order. Either decision gives you a way to tell whether the money was well spent.

Talk with Tim about your next growth investment.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Tim Williams

Founder of Accelyst Group. Executive advisory and hands-on delivery across business strategy, commercial performance, and technology.

Meet Tim Williams →

A PRACTICAL NEXT STEP

Put the thinking to work.

Talk with Tim about what these ideas could mean for your business and where to begin.

Discuss your priorities →